A Brief Introduction to the Lingnan School and the Three Lingnan Masters
Au Ho-Nien
Honorary Chief Curator of Lingnan Fine Arts Museum
When speaking of the new changes in modern Chinese painting, one cannot but give first mention to the Three Masters of the Lingnan School centered in Guangdong. This is certainly because they were the first to advocate the reorganization of Chinese painting and initiate the new style. We may note that the Lingnan School is also called the “School of Compromise” for its willingness to draw compromises between ancient and modern, Chinese and foreign. It was long in coming, following the new wave of revolution among the Chinese, and it formed a powerful force for innovation.
Each of the Three Masters of the Lingnan School—Gao Jian-fu, Gao Qi-feng, and Chen Shu-ren—studied under Ju Lian (styled Gu-quan), who resided at the “Hall of the Zither Whistling at the Moon” at Geshan, which is in Panyu County, Guangdong. In his youth, Ju enjoyed equal fame throughout Lingnan (Guangdong), had studied the two earlier masters of bird-and-flower painting Hua Yan (whose sobriquet was Xin-luo Shan-ren; 1682-1756) and Yun Shou-ping (styled Nan-tian; 1633-1690), and having focused their attention on depicting flowers, other plants, and insects from life, they achieved a rapport with nature that they converted into their own methods. They had rejected a competitive lifestyle and sought only to express themselves through painting. Living quietly, they planted their own flowers and trees and raised insects for use as reference in their painting. Their works, therefore, show a wild ease and pure splendor, not conceding any monopoly on beauty to Xu Xi (d. before 975) of the Five Dynasties era. Moreover, in their creation of the method of applying white powdered pigment to still-drying watercolor, in their use of attractive coloration, and in striking an appropriate balance between fineness and density, their ideas surpassed the ancients. Since Gao Jian-fu, Gao Qi-feng, and Chen Shu-ren all belonged to the same school, they would frequently learn from one another and discuss painting; each considered the pursuit of verisimilitude and beauty most important. Their special emphasis on the observation and experience of objective things, in fact, relates substantially to their later success. Chen Shuren, who was Ju Lian’s grand nephew-in-law, was most steeped in the Ju cousins’ teachings, so Chen’s works were also very transparent and unrestrained. Later on, he and Gao Jian-fu simultaneously went to Japan to study painting, and Gao Qi-feng followed them there. Together they joined Sun Yat-sen’s revolutionary alliance in Japan. Under the influence of artistic thinking from abroad, they thought that Chinese painting likewise could no longer adhere stubbornly to former rules, and that new changes would be inevitable. Moreover, as their daily observations on things grew deeper, they realized that Chinese and Western painting had certain points in common, and as a consequence, they made reference to principles of Western painting in their own practice. Although Western painting at the time still put extreme emphasis on verisimilitude and its practices could not be fully mixed with those of Chinese painting, which emphasized the realm of the spirit, the Three Masters could still make good use of the principles of Western painting while rejecting its hidebound formulas, so that they could enrich the content of Chinese painting itself. Given the Three Masters’ abundant natural talents, high level of education, and their spirit of consistently searching for change, their works could always refine Chinese and Western elements, and they wrote a new page in the history of Chinese painting. They had also served for a time among Sun Yat-sen’s troops during the 1911 revolution, and as a result of their experience of the rage and turbulence of revolution, their ways of thinking may also be described as complex and expansive. As their work gradually transformed the “wild ease and pure splendor” of the Geshan style to something more expansive and heroic, they tallied with the spirit of the times, and this became the greatest distinctive characteristic of the Lingnan school.
Although the Three Masters’ are renowned for their heroic style, as far as the expression of their subject matter is concerned, whether in terms of composition, brushwork, refinement of concept, balanced attention to both the form and spirit of the objects depicted, and recession into distance, even those who study Western-style drawing and perspective have much to admire here. For their ability to convey both hard and soft and to integrate both Chinese and foreign principles, one might almost use the phrase “the guts of a swordsman and the heart of a musician” to describe them. Qing dynasty painting was influenced by classificatory schemes under which paintings were deemed as belonging either to the Wu or Zhe schools of the Ming, or to Dong Qi-chang’s so-called Southern or Northern schools (in which the South was revered and the North despised); scholars thus tended to assign painters to one group or another. Objectively speaking, while those who studied the Southern or Wu schools well had a literary flavor, those who studied the Northern or Zhe schools certainly had an untrammeled spirit and an antique simplicity. Therefore, in its adoption of ancient models, the Lingnan school of painting did not put one school over another, let alone imitate them. They combined and refined both the literary elegance of the Southern school and the heroic quality of the Northern, but always they returned to the true interest of nature.
The Three Masters’ style could conform with those of older masters as well as be distinct from them. For instance, Gao Jian-fu’s Wind in the Pines, Moon Reflected in the Water (Songfeng shuiyue) depicts not only the image of the moon’s reflection in the water but also the emotion it evokes. His Poet of the South (Nanguo shiren) depicts, amidst the bold sketchwork, the poet’s gentility and sincerity, but the poet’s feelings of anxiety for the nation also flows out from between his eyebrows. Gao Qi-feng’s The Mountains Are High, the Rivers Long (Shan gao shui chang) depicts an old man in the mountains crossing a bridge on a donkey; the desolate yet elegant quality and the high delicacy of the painting’s concept may be found precisely in the bridge and the donkey’s back. As for his other masterworks such as Autumn River and White Horse (Qiu shui bai ma), Lion (Xiongshi), and Sea Eagle (Haiyan), which Sun Yat-sen had acknowledged as representative of the revolutionary spirit and esthetic of the new era, their fame does not derive from the words of historians who admired the revolutionary cause or to their close connection with a great figure. That is, the artist’s genius is plainly revealed through the balance between the restraint of the brushwork and the boldness and elegance of the compositional ideas. Consequently, one does not regret that the two Gaos did not look to ancient models—only that the ancient models did not see the two Gaos work! Therefore, in a poem written to extol them, Qiu Feng-jia (1864-1912; styled Cang-hai) wrote: “In Lingnan’s talk of the day, / The two Gaos tower over their era. / After their return from abroad, their brushes, in particular, had changed; / Reds and greens began to generate splendid novelties.” He also wrote: “Qi-feng’s peak and Jian-fu’s sword— / I beg them to depict me carrying a sword and watching the waterfall at Mount Kunlun.” To laud Gao Jian-fu’s work, he also wrote a line, “Old Jian-fu’s ambition startles the mountain demons.” He also wrote: “Yesterday, hearing that Big Gao had suddenly painted a tiger, / A swarm of heroes in the grassy marshes vied, startled, to catch it. / With painted tigers outpricing real ones, / A piece of paper worth thousands creates its own wind and thunder.” From this one can get a glimpse of how highly the Gaos were esteemed by the worthies of their time. As for Chen Shu-ren, in addition to his usual bird-and-flower paintings, he was especially fond of painting actual landscapes. Dotted amongst the scenery, one often sees suitable idle figures dressed in the fashionable clothes of Chen’s era. Sometimes among them a couple—actually the artist and his wife, who were very close and often traveled together—may be seen. Therefore, Chen also took aspects of his own life and blended them into his paintings, and in bringing out true feeling amidst true landscapes, he exemplifies the statement, “Even though no brushstroke emulates the ancients, each one does.” Clearly, each of the Three Masters has his own way of explicating and expressing things, whether regular or unusual, and they differ despite their underlying harmony. As they drew from the spirit of Chinese culture, they opened a new leaf in the history of modern painting.
